Find the number that actually matters
First thing I do is grab two numbers off the page: total elevation gain and total distance. Divide gain by distance and you get feet of vert per mile, which is the single best one-number read on how hard a course is. Total gain alone fools you, because 10,000 feet over 100 miles is rolling and runnable, while 10,000 feet over 30 miles is a different sport. Get the per-mile number first and you instantly know roughly what kind of day you are signing up for.
Then walk the line left to right and mark the features. Where are the long sustained climbs? How steep do they look? Where are the long descents that are going to wreck your quads? Which stretches are flat and runnable? You are building a mental movie of the day, climb by climb, so nothing on race day is a surprise.